Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
+15
Darth Dingbat
FrolickingFizzgig
Little_Boots
MyOnlyHope
reylo1992
IoJovi
snufkin
ZioRen
Magnolia_3.0
BastilaBey
Rimfaxe96
spacebaby45678
Reylo Lemon
Mana
Gemini
19 posters
Page 1 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
Hello. Just thought I'd add this here as a request to stop flagging the video where someone is getting mass amount of views off of other people's theories (including mine) he has now credited me and others. He still has not credited me for the Joan of arc linknto kylo but he has credited me for the saber theory.
I thought I'd make a thread because I was angry yesterday and ranted in several places. Just want to say thanks to those who helped and just bring it to one place so people would be aware to stop flagging
Thanks to gwendy and spacebaby as well for helping as well with the artwork part and finally pushing him to add credits
I thought I'd make a thread because I was angry yesterday and ranted in several places. Just want to say thanks to those who helped and just bring it to one place so people would be aware to stop flagging
Thanks to gwendy and spacebaby as well for helping as well with the artwork part and finally pushing him to add credits
Last edited by Gemini on Sat 07 Jan 2017, 10:07 am; edited 1 time in total
Gemini- Force Ghost
- Messages : 3470
Likes : 13943
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-26
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
Hey Gem, I saw that and it really pissed me off too...that was all YOUR hard work!!!
Mana- Force Ghost
- Messages : 1464
Likes : 12555
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-26
Age : 32
Localisation : Australia
Reylo Lemon- Force Ghost
- Messages : 2798
Likes : 12466
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-26
Age : 37
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
Good! Your theories is what really made that video work! and it is convincing many people. He believes in Rey being half Kenobi and Half Palpatine, but i can't wait for his Rey and Kylo will fall in love video...
spacebaby45678- Force Ghost
- Messages : 3957
Likes : 9568
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-25
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
Thanks guys!
Wow it's at 150,000 views
Wow it's at 150,000 views
Gemini- Force Ghost
- Messages : 3470
Likes : 13943
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-26
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
Still not trusting that YouTuber, the only good thing is that he's apparently got quite the audience with over 150k+ clicks.
Also my favourite comments are
Also my favourite comments are
this reply made me belive in reylo
So Luke and Rey are going to create the powerful Skywalker/Kenobi hybrid.
Stop being so convincing, you are confusing me as hell
Rimfaxe96- Force Ghost
- Messages : 1088
Likes : 6116
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-27
Age : 27
Localisation : Germany
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
@Rimfaxe96Rimfaxe96 wrote:Still not trusting that YouTuber, the only good thing is that he's apparently got quite the audience with over 150k+ clicks.
Also my favourite comments arethis reply made me belive in reyloSo Luke and Rey are going to create the powerful Skywalker/Kenobi hybrid.Stop being so convincing, you are confusing me as hell
this reply made me belive in reylo
Besides giving Gemini the attention she so richly deserves for her keen observations, the Reylo part is the sweetest victory.. I have always contended that Rey being a Kenobi makes the path to Reylo that much more obvious.
spacebaby45678- Force Ghost
- Messages : 3957
Likes : 9568
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-25
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
Nice one gem. I saw the video because someone sent me an ask about it on tumblr and as I started watching I was like erm...this is gem's stuff. I really was expecting you to have a credit at the end, as well as Gwendy for the art. Glad its opening people up to other theories besides Reywalker and Rey solo.
BastilaBey- Force Ghost
- Messages : 2350
Likes : 23523
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-25
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
@GeminiGemini wrote:Hello. Just thought I'd add this here as a request to stop flagging the video where someone is getting mass amount of views off of other people's theories (including mine) he has now credited me and others. He still has not credited me for the Joan of arc linknto kylo but he has credited me for the saber theory.
I thought I'd make a thread because I was angry yesterday and ranted in several places. Just want to say thanks to those who helped and just bring it to one place so people would be aware to stop flagging
Thanks to gwendy and spacebaby as well for helping as well with the artwork part and finally pushing him to add credits
The video is below and it's pretty good. He's a reylo shipper to boot!
His video was very well done, but I want to congratulate you on Obi Wan Kenobi's lightsaber theory. I read your theory some time ago, and I never left it, I found it incredible and I believe it seriously! Perfect, congratulations!
Magnolia_3.0- Jedi Youngling
- Messages : 93
Likes : 194
Date d'inscription : 2016-11-17
Age : 37
Localisation : Brazil
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
@Magnolia_3.0Magnolia_3.0 wrote:@GeminiGemini wrote:Hello. Just thought I'd add this here as a request to stop flagging the video where someone is getting mass amount of views off of other people's theories (including mine) he has now credited me and others. He still has not credited me for the Joan of arc linknto kylo but he has credited me for the saber theory.
I thought I'd make a thread because I was angry yesterday and ranted in several places. Just want to say thanks to those who helped and just bring it to one place so people would be aware to stop flagging
Thanks to gwendy and spacebaby as well for helping as well with the artwork part and finally pushing him to add credits
The video is below and it's pretty good. He's a reylo shipper to boot!
His video was very well done, but I want to congratulate you on Obi Wan Kenobi's lightsaber theory. I read your theory some time ago, and I never left it, I found it incredible and I believe it seriously! Perfect, congratulations!
Thank you
You know I'm still kind of pissed and will be messaging him later. When it comes to the saber part he is literally reading my thmblr post word for word and passing it of as his own. He should have mentioned me in the video. In the comments everyone is congratulating him on "cracking the secret" it's infuriating. I realised this possible outcome in June last year and over many months and thanks to mrs Ben solo etc with articles managed to piece a lot more together about the clan. It was hard work, lots of sources and he just freaking stole it.
I wish I sat on this theory and did a video like this rather than write about it everywhere. I realised this last month. Way too late.
Gemini- Force Ghost
- Messages : 3470
Likes : 13943
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-26
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
This is also all about sexism and misogyny. I can't help but feel this way
Men steal women's ideas and pass them off as their own since the dawn of time. I feel like if I was a man, this would not have happened and he would have credited me.
Also it's frustrating how the second the theory comes out of a mans mouth it's listened to and appreciated by other men and fanboys
Maybe I'm crazy lol
Men steal women's ideas and pass them off as their own since the dawn of time. I feel like if I was a man, this would not have happened and he would have credited me.
Also it's frustrating how the second the theory comes out of a mans mouth it's listened to and appreciated by other men and fanboys
Maybe I'm crazy lol
Gemini- Force Ghost
- Messages : 3470
Likes : 13943
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-26
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
Nah, Gem. I'm sure he would have done it regardless of your gender. People always want all the glory. If they can pass off everything as theirs with no complaints, they make out like bandits. Unfortunately for him you didn't take it lying down.
I think more people listen to him because he already had a built in audience (though yes, fanboys definitely take male opinions more seriously. I bet if more male fans supported Reylo, it wouldn't be seen as such a ridiculous idea). Which makes me glad that he even somewhat listened to you and added credits. A lot of those people just swing their fandom weight around and crush anyone they stole from who has a lesser audience because their people back them up.
I think more people listen to him because he already had a built in audience (though yes, fanboys definitely take male opinions more seriously. I bet if more male fans supported Reylo, it wouldn't be seen as such a ridiculous idea). Which makes me glad that he even somewhat listened to you and added credits. A lot of those people just swing their fandom weight around and crush anyone they stole from who has a lesser audience because their people back them up.
ZioRen- Force Ghost
- Messages : 3117
Likes : 21570
Date d'inscription : 2016-05-27
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
@Gemini
Unfortunately we still live in an extremely sexist world! But do not be annoyed, in the groups that I participate the vast majority know that this theory is yours, I say this because we have already discussed exhaustively about it. My friends from the group on Facebook met through your Tumblr, myself before participating in this forum. I liked the Youtuber video, but honestly it was just a well done plagiarism ... it did not bring anything new, just presented in a different way ...
Unfortunately we still live in an extremely sexist world! But do not be annoyed, in the groups that I participate the vast majority know that this theory is yours, I say this because we have already discussed exhaustively about it. My friends from the group on Facebook met through your Tumblr, myself before participating in this forum. I liked the Youtuber video, but honestly it was just a well done plagiarism ... it did not bring anything new, just presented in a different way ...
Magnolia_3.0- Jedi Youngling
- Messages : 93
Likes : 194
Date d'inscription : 2016-11-17
Age : 37
Localisation : Brazil
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
@GeminiGemini wrote:This is also all about sexism and misogyny. I can't help but feel this way
Men steal women's ideas and pass them off as their own since the dawn of time. I feel like if I was a man, this would not have happened and he would have credited me.
Also it's frustrating how the second the theory comes out of a mans mouth it's listened to and appreciated by other men and fanboys
Maybe I'm crazy lol
It sounds like fanboy theories get a Hell of a lot more respect than shipping, so yes there's an element of sexism in whether it's respected or mocked. Glad you at least forced him into giving credit, but that's still pretty s***ty plagiarizing what you wrote and presenting it like he thought of it himself.
snufkin- Force Ghost
- Messages : 8649
Likes : 40499
Date d'inscription : 2016-04-16
Localisation : it's in the chorus of Pavement's "Unfair"
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
@ZioRenZioRen wrote:Nah, Gem. I'm sure he would have done it regardless of your gender. People always want all the glory. If they can pass off everything as theirs with no complaints, they make out like bandits. Unfortunately for him you didn't take it lying down.
I think more people listen to him because he already had a built in audience (though yes, fanboys definitely take male opinions more seriously. I bet if more male fans supported Reylo, it wouldn't be seen as such a ridiculous idea). Which makes me glad that he even somewhat listened to you and added credits. A lot of those people just swing their fandom weight around and crush anyone they stole from who has a lesser audience because their people back them up.
I don't think this guy targeted @Gemini to steal her work based on her gender, but I would be lying if I said I didn't think gender played a part in the amount of positive attention this video is receiving. Â That's part of what makes me so angry about this whole thing on Gem's behalf. Â
I'm glad he's finally credited you on 90% of the researched that's yours in this video, but I wouldn't stop pushing until he gives you all of it. Â
This whole thing still sucks all the way around because had he not gotten the massive amount of pressure from basically all over the Internet, I think would it have gone ignored.
IoJovi- Force Ghost
- Messages : 7289
Likes : 41511
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-25
Age : 107
Localisation : Atlanta, GA
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
I knew it was coming the second the obi wan spoilers and rumours started picking up lol. I knew it was only a matter of time before someone picked up on it and would use it for personal gain it sucks
Gemini- Force Ghost
- Messages : 3470
Likes : 13943
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-26
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
Glad for you @gemini. You deserve to earn the credit for your brillant theories!
reylo1992- Force Ghost
- Messages : 1721
Likes : 7036
Date d'inscription : 2016-07-22
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
@GeminiGemini wrote:You know I'm still kind of pissed and will be messaging him later. When it comes to the saber part he is literally reading my thmblr post word for word and passing it of as his own. He should have mentioned me in the video.
This. I don't see why he couldn't mention you - or gwendy, whose art he took - in the video.
See, this is why I don't care for "big YouTubers" or any Star Wars videos in general (except for clips from the movies), it lacks creativity like Hollywood. Worse than Hollywood actually - if Hollywood directors would just downright steal things 1:1 from their colleagues, there'd be hell to pay in court. And little boys just reading theories or lore explanations from wiki's other people have worked really hard on for years is just plain lazy (and regarding the lore videos often less than precise).
Nothankyou, I'll rather stick to Animash videos.
Rimfaxe96- Force Ghost
- Messages : 1088
Likes : 6116
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-27
Age : 27
Localisation : Germany
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
Looks like mike zeroh has also taken my idea..I can't even watch it but he's talking about both sabers now too
What a joke
I just can't with this I'm really upset
What a joke
I just can't with this I'm really upset
Gemini- Force Ghost
- Messages : 3470
Likes : 13943
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-26
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
@gemini That sucks but please don't take it personally. Mike Zeroh has stolen from MSW and they are the big leagues. He doesn't give a f***, it's pretty awful. We're your friends and we know it's your theory. And if it all turns out to be the accurate story, you'll feel the satisfaction for sure
BastilaBey- Force Ghost
- Messages : 2350
Likes : 23523
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-25
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
@BastilaBeyBastilaBey wrote:@gemini That sucks but please don't take it personally. Mike Zeroh has stolen from MSW and they are the big leagues. He doesn't give a f***, it's pretty awful. We're your friends and we know it's your theory. And if it all turns out to be the accurate story, you'll feel the satisfaction for sure
Yeah I see what you mean, there's no point in me really fighting this.
Thanks for your support.
I'm just very passionate about this one particular theory and just put a lot of effort into it and it never paid off or picked up really and it's just frustrating how other people use it and put in zero effort and get a huge response.
It's not the first time this has happened to me either.
It may even be wrong, imagine lol.
But from that moment I had that instant lightbulb moment 6 months ago it's been a passion and it sucks
Gemini- Force Ghost
- Messages : 3470
Likes : 13943
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-26
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
And the Vader castle thing mike mentions there...I think they are spying here
Something has alerted these big guns to my theory and it's like they both raced to get it out
Something has alerted these big guns to my theory and it's like they both raced to get it out
Gemini- Force Ghost
- Messages : 3470
Likes : 13943
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-26
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
Contact YouTube. They'll take them down because of copyright issues in no time.
edit; There you go: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2807622?hl=en&visit_id=1-636193351144089159-875668314&rd=1
Click "SUBMIT A COPYRIGHT COMPLAINT". Alternatively you may just write an e-mail and they'll take them down.
Frankly, you should do it - would serve them right. Idiots.
edit; There you go: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2807622?hl=en&visit_id=1-636193351144089159-875668314&rd=1
Click "SUBMIT A COPYRIGHT COMPLAINT". Alternatively you may just write an e-mail and they'll take them down.
Frankly, you should do it - would serve them right. Idiots.
Rimfaxe96- Force Ghost
- Messages : 1088
Likes : 6116
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-27
Age : 27
Localisation : Germany
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
@Rimfaxe96Rimfaxe96 wrote:Contact YouTube. They'll take them down because of copyright issues in no time.
edit; There you go: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2807622?hl=en&visit_id=1-636193351144089159-875668314&rd=1
Click "SUBMIT A COPYRIGHT COMPLAINT". Alternatively you may just write an e-mail and they'll take them down.
Frankly, you should do it - would serve them right. Idiots.
Thank you for that
They won't take zerohs down though
Gemini- Force Ghost
- Messages : 3470
Likes : 13943
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-26
Re: Thanks to everyone for helping, he's credited my theory now
@GeminiGemini wrote:Thank you for that
They won't take zerohs down though
Why wouldn't they? Copyright is copyright, no matter who ignores it?
Rimfaxe96- Force Ghost
- Messages : 1088
Likes : 6116
Date d'inscription : 2016-03-27
Age : 27
Localisation : Germany
Page 1 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
Similar topics
» Lightsaber crystals: new canon
» Theory: Lord Cronal/Blackhole/Shadowspawn is Snoke
» Theory and Ramblings- The rise of the FO, Rey's origin and Balance to the Force
» The Last Jedi: General Discussion
» Theory: Lord Cronal/Blackhole/Shadowspawn is Snoke
» Theory and Ramblings- The rise of the FO, Rey's origin and Balance to the Force
» The Last Jedi: General Discussion
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|